Get Adobe Flash player

DNAR: Do Not Attempt Resurrection

I had never thought about the confusion the public might have between resuscitation and resurrection until I saw mention of a poem in October by Dr. Brenda Butka. The section that caught my attention was:

I can say
do not confuse resuscitation
with resurrection, although
neither works particularly well

Indeed, it does seem as if the way CPR is typically discussed implies resurrection as in, “If your heart were to stop (and you would technically be dead) would you like us to try to restart it (ie resurrect you)”? No wonder people find this an appealing concept.
We know that when we present CPR differently, people make different choices. When we talk about goals of care and values, vs. technology, people often opt for less aggressive methods. And educating them about the realities of CPR results in their making different choices. For instance, a recent study in the Journal of Oncology found that showing people with cancer a video of what CPR really involves resulted in less of them choosing to be a full code (all heroic resuscitation measures including cardiopulmonary technological support). Perhaps, when tablet technology is more accessible in our healthcare institutions, we can use such videos and more appropriate conversations to help people understand that we’re not in the resurrection business.

Related posts:

  • http://ThroughLifeAndDeath.com Shahina Lakhani

    Marian, I never thought of resuscitation as resurrection either. This article helps me understand why people might be so opposed to DNR I have seen some organizations use “Allow Natural Death” or “AND” instead of DNR and people seemed to receive it much better. I think it is because the terms implies that we are not taking anything away but only allowing the natural process of death to occur when their body can no longer sustain itself.

  • http://www.indoneka.com/aksesoris_mobil/allproducts/aksesoris-mobil/aksesoris-toyota/grand-new-innova.html Aksesoris Modifikasi Innova

    That’s right, I agree what’s that Shahina Lakhani said

  • Marian Grant NP

    I also agree that using different terms such as the ones below may help people better understand what’s really an option.

  • http://www.jakartastory.com/2013/01/cara-praktis-menghilangkan-bau-mulut.html Menghilangkan Bau Mulut

    It’s true and I agree what you said that only allowing the natural process of death.

Can We Talk?
Watch and share this five minute video about the need for prophylactic end-of-life conversations. Laura Heldebrand, an ICU nurse tells her mother's story.
High Traffic Alert !
Your JPM blog is a high traffic site. We have 1406 subscribers. In August 2012, we had 140,372 hits (this number is excluding bots and spider traffic)! Many thanks to you all for your love and support of your Journal of Palliative Medicine.
Get Involved: Build Your JPM Network
Please become an active member and a local leader of the JPM Social Media community. Ask your friends and trainees to sign up for the free, full-text JPM blog posts.

Do email us now and take a hand in shaping your favorite palliative care journal, be it as a user, a local chapter advocate or panelist. We are waiting to hear from you.
Subscribe Free: JPM Updates
JPM Community Chatter
Follow this JPM Blog
Archives
  • 2013
  • 2012
  • 2011